
The Mills Mock Trial team at the final Northern San Mateo County Mock Trial Competition round that secured Mills' first place finish. The team advances to semi-finals against Hillsdale on February 28.
The Mills Mock Trial team advances to the semi-final round of the San Mateo County Mock Trial competition on Tuesday, February 28, following a first place finish in three preliminary competition rounds.
The Mills team advances with South City High School from the Northern San Mateo County division to the semi-final round where the two teams will faced off with the San Mateo County Southern Branch victors, Hillsdale High School and Menlo School, respectively. The competition took place at the Superior Court of San Mateo County. History teacher Ms. Campbell is the teacher advisor, and practicing attorneys Dennis Zell and Rolando Pasquali are the attorney coaches of this year’s team.
The California Mock Trial Program, sponsored by the Constitutional Rights Foundation, presents Mock Trial participants with a criminal case each fall. Cases include testimonies of fictional witnesses, upon which the trial is based. Student participants prepare for trial for most of the year, studying and preparing their cases under the guidance of teacher advisors and attorney coaches. A team is divided into the Prosecution and the Defense. Students may play attorneys, witnesses, bailiffs, clerks, or courtroom artists in the mock renditions of real-life court proceedings. A trial is composed of two motions. First is a preliminary pre-trial motion brought by the defense to exclude the second count with which the Prosecution wants to charge the defendant. The second motion constitutes the actual trial, during which witnesses present evidence on both sides.
This year’s case was a murder trial featuring a pretrial motion on the constitutionality of the California Concealed Carry Statute. The prosecution charged Ryan Buschell, with the second-degree murder of Becca Abeles. Mock Trial is an intellectually stimulating activity that requires attorneys and witnesses on both sides to think fast on their feet and to argue their theories using adequate knowledge of the law.
Junior Valerie Fates, who acted the defendant in this year’s trial said, “Acting as the defendant in a murder trial s very difficult. The defendant has to give the right impression to the trier of fact, the judge. I can’t act too happy and I can’t act too sad. I have to earn the judge’s sympathy and know my facts really well.”
Despite the challenge, however, Mills Mock Trial participants enjoy the instruction on law and the benefits of teamwork that they receive in return for their hard work and dedication.
Senior and student Defense lawyer Raymond Tong who is in his second year in Mock Trial said, “I returned this year because Mock Trial is something I really enjoy. It gives me a chance to learn something that the normal school curriculum doesn’t teach me.”
The team attributes its success in the courtroom to the help and guidance it received from Ms. Campbell and its two attorney coaches during practice this year.
Tong said, “I think we owe most of it [our success] to our attorney coaches and Ms. Campbell for helping us out so much.”
Despite the success it has had thus far, however, the team understands that it will be facing a different kind of competition in the semi-final round. Menlo School and Hillsdale High School have consistently been at the top of their game, as defending California State Mock Trial Champion and former California State Mock Trial Champion, respectively. Nevertheless, the team feels confident heading into semi-finals and is proud of its accomplishments regardless of what the final outcome may be.
Mock Trial participants are scored based on their presentations in the courtroom by practicing attorneys who are the judges. Student attorneys are scored based on their overall knowledge of the law and their abilities to construct direct and cross-examinations, present opening and closing statements, and respond to trial proceedings with the appropriate objections. Student witnesses are scored on their believability playing their character, and their responses in dealing with the opposing counsel’s cross-examinations.
This is the second time Mills Mock Trial has advanced to the semi-final round in three years. The team finds out whether it will advance to final round of the county mock trial competition on Wednesday, February 29.





















